The successful management of
controlled drainage
systems focuses on two important
objectives. The first is achieving optimum production efficiency and maximum nutrient
utilization by the crop; the second is attaining maximum water quality benefits.
Controlled drainage structures require that the topography be relatively flat. The costs
to production and water quality will usually exceed benefits when the land slope exceeds
0.5%. As a consequence, controlled drainage is most practical in the Lower
Coastal Plain and Tidewater regions of North Carolina. The predominant cropping
sequence in these areas is a two-year rotation of corn, wheat, and soybean. General
guidelines for management of controlled drainage under this cropping sequence are
given in Table 1.
The general guidelines present an attempt to achieve a balance between production and
water quality goals. Many of the management indicators are hidden from view, and the
response to adjustments is not immediate. Intensive management with long- term monitoring
is necessary to develop a site-specific understanding of the system. Productivity
and water goals are compatible during some years, or at least seasonally during most
the year. Under some conditions, however, productivity, water quality, or both goals
may need to be mutually compromised for the benefit of the other. For example, management
throughout the year is necessary to achieve maximum water quality benefit
and drainage control to reduce nitrogen transport is most effective during winter and
early spring periods. When fields are fallow, there is no significant production cost
associated with holding water levels high to achieve the maximum water quality benefit.
But productivity of some crops such as winter wheat may be reduced by high
winter water table levels.
Table 1. General water table management guidelines to promote water quality and
optimum crop yields for a two-year rotation of corn-wheat-soybeans (from Evans et al.,
1991).
Jan. 1 – Mar. 15
Fallow
12 – 18
Minimize drainage outflow
and encourage denitrification.
Mar. 15 – Apr. 5
Tillage, corn seedbed preparation, planting
30 – 36
Just deep enough to provide trafficability and good conditions for seedbed preparation.
Apr. 15 – May 15
Corn establishment,
early growth
24 – 30
Deep enough to promote good early growth root development
Nitrogen sidedressing
24 – 36
Just low enough to allow trafficability
May 15 – Aug. 15
Corn development and maturity
18 – 24
Temporary adjustment during wet periods
Aug. 15 – Oct. 15
Harvesting, tillage;
planting of wheat
30 – 36
Lower enough to provide trafficability
Oct. 15 – Mar. 1
Wheat establishment
18 – 24
Lower during extremely wet periods
Mar. 1 – Mar. 15
Sidedressing wheat
30 – 36
Low enough to provide trafficability
Mar. 15 – Jun. 15
Wheat development
18 – 24
Temporary adjustment during wet periods
Jun. 15 – Jul. 15
Harvesting wheat; tillage, planting of soybeans
30 – 36
Depends on rainfall
Jul. 15 – Nov. 1
Soybean development
18 – 24
Temporary adjustment to allow cultivation
Nov. 1 – Dec. 15
Soybean harvesting
36 – 42
Low enough to provide trafficability
Dec. 15 – Mar. 15
Fallow
12 – 18
Minimize drainage outflow and encourage denitrification
a Values shown are the control setting (depth below average surface elevation) and should not be considered
the actual water table depth in the field, which will be lower except during drainage periods.
b Most adjustments are related to trafficability and must take into account weather conditions and soil water
status at the time:
– in an unusually dry season, control can be 3 to 6 inches higher;
– in an unusually wet season, control should be 3 to 6 inches lower;
– in coarse-textured soils, trafficability can be provided with the water table approximately 6 inches higher.